Asda and Iceland mince pies win a Which? Best Buy award in blind taste test

Budget supermarkets Asda and Iceland came out on top in a blind Christmas taste test conducted by consumer brand Which? – while Sainsbury’s and Morrisons scored the lowest.

The Asda Extra Special Mince Pies, priced at £1.75 for six (or 29p per pie) lived up to their name, scoring a 73 per cent rating for their flavour, texture and appearance.

The Which? panel noted their ‘crisp’ and ‘buttery’ pastry and the intricate design of the Asda pies, with one panelist saying it would ‘lure them in’. 

Meanwhile Iceland’s Luxury All Butter Mince Pies (£1.89 for six – 31p per pie) were rated just as highly for their taste, aroma and texture, and also bagged a rating of 73 per cent.

The Asda Extra Special Mince Pies, priced at £1.75 for six (or 29p per pie) lived up to their name, scoring a 73 per cent rating for their flavour, texture and appearance

The Asda Extra Special Mince Pies, priced at £1.75 for six (or 29p per pie) lived up to their name, scoring a 73 per cent rating for their flavour, texture and appearance

Iceland's Luxury All Butter Mince Pies (£1.89 for six - 31p per pie) were rated just as highly for their taste, aroma and texture, and also bagged a rating of 73 per cent

Iceland’s Luxury All Butter Mince Pies (£1.89 for six – 31p per pie) were rated just as highly for their taste, aroma and texture, and also bagged a rating of 73 per cent

One panelist told Which? these pies ‘tasted like a more expensive product’. Iceland also fared well in the Good Housekeeping annual taste test, coming a close second to High Street chain Costa Coffee with a score of 87/100.

As a result of coming out on top, both received a coveted Which? Best Buy award.     

Tesco Finest All Butter Mince Pies (£1.75 for six – 29p per pie) narrowly missed out on a Best Buy award, winning a 72 per cent rating.

While these pies delivered and the pastry was described as ‘melt in the mouth’ by one taster, a few panellists were less keen on the firmer filling.

WHICH? BEST MINCE PIES IN 2020 
BRANDSCORE  %PRICE 
Asda Extra Special Mince Pies73£1.75 for 6 
Iceland’s Luxury All Butter Mince Pies 73 £1.89 for 6 
Tesco Finest All Butter Mince Pies 72 £1.75 for 6 
M&S Collection Mince Pies 71 £2.50 for 6 
Aldi Specially Selected Mince Pies 68 £1.49 for 6 
Lidl Deluxe All Butter Mince Pies 68 £1.49 for 6 
Waitrose No 1 All Butter Mince Pies 68 £2.50 for 6 
Co-op Irresistible All-butter Mince Pies 66 £2 for 6 
Spar Luxury All Butter Mince Pies 66 £2 for 6 
Morrisons The Best Mince Pies 64 £2 for 6 
Sainsbury’s Taste the Difference Mince Pies 58 £2 for 6 
Down at the bottom of the table, Sainsbury's Taste the Difference Mince Pies (£2 for six - 33p per pie) fared worst in the taste tests

Down at the bottom of the table, Sainsbury’s Taste the Difference Mince Pies (£2 for six – 33p per pie) fared worst in the taste tests

Morrisons The Best Mince Pies (£2 for six - 33p per pie) were also a disappointment, managing a score of just 64 per cent, with more than half the panel describing them as 'too dark'

Morrisons The Best Mince Pies (£2 for six – 33p per pie) were also a disappointment, managing a score of just 64 per cent, with more than half the panel describing them as ‘too dark’

M&S Collection mince pies (£2.50 for six – 41p per pie) were some of the pricier pies included in the taste tests, but these had some of the best pastry sampled, as well as scoring well for flavour. 

The luxurious pies received a not-too-shabby rating of 71 per cent.

Down at the bottom of the table, Sainsbury’s Taste the Difference Mince Pies (£2 for six – 33p per pie) fared worst in the taste tests.

They earned a distinctly average 58 per cent score, with some scathing panelists admitting they found them ‘claggy’ and thought they tasted ‘stale’ and ‘overcooked’.

Spar, which recorded its first win in BBC Good Food Magazine's blind taste test last month, was third from bottom, scoring 66 per cent

Spar, which recorded its first win in BBC Good Food Magazine’s blind taste test last month, was third from bottom, scoring 66 per cent

Morrisons The Best Mince Pies (£2 for six – 33p per pie) were also a disappointment, managing a score of just 64 per cent, with more than half the panel describing them as ‘too dark’.

Spar, which recorded its first win in BBC Good Food Magazine’s blind taste test last month, was third from bottom, scoring 66 per cent. 

The Which? mince pie panel this year consisted of 64 consumers who broadly represent the demographic make-up of the UK, and regularly consume mince pies. 

Harry Rose, editor of Which? Magazine, said: ‘Nothing tastes more festive than a delicious warm and crumbly mince pie straight from the oven, and while this year Christmas might be a little different, we want to make sure that at least your mince pies don’t disappoint.’ 

Recommended


Makeup Tips To Look Younger

Fashion Tips

Hair Care Tips

Fashion Tips For Girls